PermitNotebook / Guides

Guide

Historic Districts and the Certificate of Appropriateness

National Register listing alone puts no federal limit on what a private owner does. A local historic district does: its review board approves exterior changes, often including work that needs no building permit, such as a fence, a roof, a small shed or new deck boards. Which permit exemptions fall away in a district, from 82 rules in 44 offices, and how Tacoma's North Slope district ties review to the building permit.

If your house is in a local historic district, plan on a separate approval for most exterior changes, usually called a certificate of appropriateness, and expect it to reach work the building department would wave through. That approval comes from a historic preservation commission or review board, not the building inspector, and it is about how the change looks, not how it is built. A house that is only listed on the National Register is a different case: the federal listing by itself does not restrict a private owner.

National Register listing alone
No federal restriction on a private ownerunless federal money or a federal permit is involved
Local historic district
Review board approval for exterior workset by local ordinance
Offices in our data with historic review
4482 verified rows; roofs 25, fences 23, solar 11
Exemptions that fall away
Fences, sheds, low decks, reroofsDenver, Salt Lake City, Baltimore County, San Diego
Tacoma, North Slope district
Design review when a building permit is requiredcity design review page

Find out which kind of designation you have before you draw anything. Call the city or county planning office and ask: “Is [address] in a locally designated historic district or a designated landmark? Which exterior changes need a certificate of appropriateness there, can staff approve [my project] without a commission hearing, and what are the submission deadline and meeting date?”

National Register or local district: the difference that matters

The National Park Service answers the most common worry directly: “Under Federal Law, the listing of a property in the National Register places no restrictions on what a non-federal owner may do with their property up to and including destruction, unless the property is involved in a project that receives Federal assistance, usually funding or licensing/permitting.” It adds that listing “places no federal restrictions or requirements on a private property owner. You may do with the property as you wish, within the framework of local laws or ordinances.”

That last clause is where the rules live. States let cities and counties create local districts with real review power. Virginia’s statute, as an example, lets a locality adopt an ordinance providing “that no building or structure, including signs, shall be erected, reconstructed, altered, or restored within any such district unless approved by the review board,” and lets it bar razing, demolishing or moving a historic building until the board approves, with an appeal to the circuit court. Ask the planning office which designation your property has; a house can be on the National Register without being in a local district, and the reverse.

Where historic review reaches work that needs no permit

The most useful thing we can tell you from our dataset is which ordinary exemptions stop applying in a district. Of the offices we track, 44 write historic review into at least one of their verified rules (82 rows: 25 roof replacement, 23 fence, 11 solar, 8 shed, 5 deck, 5 patio and a few others). The exemptions they take away, as recorded in those rows:

OfficeWhat changes in a historic district
DenverFences need a permit at any height in a historic district, on a landmark or along a designated parkway (elsewhere only over 4 feet)
Salt Lake CityAn exempt shed still needs a Certificate of Appropriateness in a Local Historic District
Baltimore County, MDA low deck of 120 square feet or less needs a permit in a historic district or on the Landmarks List, and so does an accessory structure of any size
MilwaukeeIts no-permit list for replacing deck and porch boards excepts historic houses and districts
PhiladelphiaPainting, cabinets, countertops and floor coverings usually need no permit unless the property is on the Philadelphia Historic Registry
San DiegoDesignated historic properties always need a permit for any roof work
New OrleansThe permit exemption does not waive Vieux Carre Commission or Historic District Landmarks Commission review
IndianapolisA fence that needs no structural or location permit still needs a certificate of appropriateness in a historic district
Henrico County and other Virginia countiesA like-for-like reroof is exempt, but the building official may require a permit in a historic district
New York CityA fence exempt from a DOB permit must still meet any Landmarks Preservation Commission requirement

Montgomery County, Maryland, puts “Exterior Work on Historic Property” on its own list of work that will likely need a permit. Atlanta, Cincinnati, Grand Rapids, Saint Paul, Tucson and others add a certificate, a commission approval or a special district review on top of the building permit for fences, decks, sheds or roofs.

Tacoma’s North Slope: review follows the building permit

Some districts tie review to the building permit rather than to every change. Tacoma’s design review page says that “any exterior work on City Landmarks that is visible from public rights of way requires design review,” while “In the North Slope Historic District, exterior changes that require building permits also require design review.” So in North Slope the question for a new roof is first whether the reroof needs a building permit. In our dataset, Tacoma’s rule exempts a reroof of a single-family home or duplex when the old covering is removed first, the new material weighs no more than 2.5 pounds per square foot and the framing is unchanged, and requires a permit for a second layer laid over the old one. A heavier material or an overlay is therefore the job that brings in design review there; confirm a tear-off with the Historic Preservation Officer before you assume it needs none.

What the review looks at, and how long it takes

Virginia’s statute states the test a board applies: whether a change is “architecturally compatible with the historic landmarks, buildings, or structures therein.” What that means for a window, a roof color or a fence is set by each board’s design guidelines, which we did not read for this guide. Before you design, ask the office for three things: the guidelines, whether staff can approve your kind of work without a hearing, and the commission’s submission deadlines and meeting dates, since a hearing schedule can set your start date more than the building permit does.

Our guides to replacing windows, replacing siding and demolishing a shed, garage or house each note where a historic district changes the answer.

Method

We read the National Park Service FAQ, Virginia’s statute, Tacoma’s design review page and Montgomery County’s list on November 18, 2026; the quotes are theirs. The 44 offices and 82 rows are the verified (confirmed or reported) rows in our dataset whose rule mentions a historic district, landmark, heritage or preservation district, preservation commission, architectural review board district, the Vieux Carre Commission, a certificate of appropriateness or a conservation district; the table cites those rows, whose read dates are on each office’s page here. We did not read any commission’s design guidelines for this guide, so we cannot say what a given board will approve.

Historic Districts and the Certificate of Appropriateness: figures as of 28 Sep 2026, 137 jurisdictions. Now 178.

Sources

Get rule-change alerts

We catch permit rule and fee changes in our verification passes and post them to the rule tracker. Get them by email instead.

We may send occasional verified rule-change notes for your area; unsubscribe anytime. See our privacy policy.